This is a rather obscure 1992 shoe-string budget Jaws homage, with some surprisingly gruesome special effects. The cover isn’t particularly well-known, but I would say it belongs on this list because it’s great in and of itself. This was apparently a trophy dish that someone took off their father’s wall and used in a horror film—and you know what? It works. Jaws works, and so does Psycho Pike.

And as the great writer Chuck Klosterman has said, “nothing is ever really in and of itself.”